We Asked Liz Ann Sonders, Jim Grant, and Brent Donnelly What Investors Miss About This Market
TL;DR
Veteran investors Jim Grant, Liz Ann Sonders, and Brent Donnelly warn that markets are underestimating the inflationary impact of geopolitical conflict, the global nature of energy prices despite US export status, and the importance of distinguishing between structural trends and mean-reverting policy shocks in the current volatile regime.
⚔️ The Inflationary Nature of War 3 insights
War is invariably inflationary
Grant argues that while theories blaming inflation on corporate greed or monetary policy come and go, war permanently strains productive capacity, destroys resources, and requires money printing to finance destruction, making it universally inflationary across centuries.
Historical monetary regime shift
Before the 1960s, inflation was exclusively a wartime phenomenon in the US, but the shift to fiat currency (the "PhD standard") now enables inflation without warfare, with current geopolitical conflicts adding "rancid whipped cream" to monetary mismanagement.
Geopolitical flashpoints
With tensions escalating over Greenland, the Baltic Straits, and the Strait of Hormuz, war preparations are diverting production and manpower resources, threatening to perpetuate inflation well above the Fed's 2% target.
🛢️ Oil Shock Realities 3 insights
Energy vs. crude distinction
Despite being a net energy exporter, the US remains a net crude oil importer and is fully exposed to global price shocks since energy is priced in global markets regardless of domestic supply balances.
Demand destruction dynamics
While high oil prices eventually create demand destruction through "the cure for high prices is high prices," shocks simultaneously pressure growth and inflation, with Strait of Hormuz blockages threatening fertilizer and food supply chains.
K-shaped economic impact
Rising non-discretionary costs disproportionately burden lower-income consumers who spend higher percentages of income on essentials, exacerbating the K-shaped nature of the economic recovery.
📊 Positioning and Policy Reflexivity 3 insights
Regime-dependent strategies
Constant contrarianism loses money by missing structural trends, but rolling policy shocks create mean-reverting regimes where positioning and sentiment become critical trading tools.
The policy reaction function
Market moves trigger policy reflexivity where extreme price action forces governmental responses (e.g., tariff delays after crashes), creating dampening feedback loops that reverse initial shocks.
Framework selection
Investors must apply the right framework to each regime, distinguishing between lasting structural trends like Brazil's appreciation and temporary mean-reverting shocks in US markets.
Bottom Line
Investors must distinguish between lasting structural trends and temporary policy shocks while recognizing that war and energy crises create persistent inflationary pressures that transcend domestic economic conditions and trigger reflexive policy responses.
More from Excess Returns
View all
Priced for Perfection | David Rosenberg on Why Inflation Isn’t the Risk
David Rosenberg argues the current market represents the 'sixth mega bubble' of the last century, with the CAPE ratio at 40 and a zero equity risk premium, meaning investors are pricing stocks as riskless assets and should expect zero to negative returns over the next decade.
We Asked a Macro Trader Why War and Oil Haven’t Broken This Market
Macro trader Brent Donnelly explains why continuous policy shocks and geopolitical risks haven't broken the market, arguing that the U.S. economy's structural resilience and mean-reverting policy dynamics create a 'wall of worry' climb rather than a collapse, with specific strategies for trading regime changes.
The Bear Market No One Sees | Liz Ann Sonders on the Violent Rotation Investors Miss
Liz Ann Sonders reveals that while major indexes appear resilient, the market is experiencing a 'violent rotation' masking severe underlying damage, with NASDAQ constituents averaging 33% drawdowns (deep bear market territory) despite the index showing only a 13% correction, as geopolitical instability and a new class of 'short attention span' retail traders fundamentally alter market mechanics.
The Forever Invariable Truth | Jim Grant on War, Inflation, and What Comes Next
Jim Grant argues that war is inherently inflationary due to resource destruction and money printing, while the Federal Reserve's 2% target institutionalizes permanent currency debasement—a combination that threatens sustained inflation amid current geopolitical tensions.