The Stagflation Trap | Aahan Menon on What Works When Stocks and Bonds Don’t
TL;DR
With sustained inflationary pressures from energy supply shocks threatening demand destruction, investors face a potential stagflationary regime where traditional equity and bond portfolios historically underperform, necessitating immediate allocation shifts toward commodities and FX strategies.
🌍 The Stagflation Setup 3 insights
Unprecedented macro divergence
The economy shows mixed signals unseen in modern history: labor markets slow while output remains elevated due to AI capex, and consumers spend through disaving despite weak income growth.
Energy shock as recession catalyst
Sustained oil price spikes from Middle East conflict are creating month-to-month annualized CPI readings 'in the nines,' acting as the recessionary trigger that tariffs failed to deliver.
Vulnerability window widening
Consensus expectations have overshot economic reality, creating fragility that existed even before recent geopolitical shocks and threatens to tip output into contraction.
📊 Historical Regime Analysis 3 insights
The 1965-1985 precedent
Sustained inflationary periods produce asset returns opposite to recent decades: equities meander, fixed income performs terribly, while gold and commodities become the assets to own.
Portfolio design mismatch
Most investors remain constructed for disinflationary real growth with heavy equity-bond allocations, leaving them unprepared for a regime where these assets 'aren't designed to perform.'
Preparation over prediction
The critical question is not whether stagflation will occur, but whether portfolios are ready to handle sustained inflationary pressures bleeding from energy into other sectors.
📈 Expected Returns Hierarchy 3 insights
Current return rankings
Commodities—particularly energy—offer the highest expected returns today, followed by FX interest rate differentials, while equity and fixed income expected returns remain weak relative to risk.
Volatility-adjusted fixed income
While fixed income opportunities are emerging, energy-driven volatility makes the risk-adjusted returns unattractive compared to other asset classes.
Smart beta methodology
Expected returns are calculated using forward earnings yields (equities), yield curve shape (bonds), term structure (commodities), and interest rate differentials (FX) to create an adaptive global baseline.
⚡ The Commodity Dynamic 3 insights
Counterintuitive value creation
Unlike stocks and bonds where lower prices signal higher value, commodities generate best risk premiums during supply shocks when backwardation occurs and spot prices rally.
Backwardation mechanics
During supply shortages, buying oil futures 6-24 months out captures convergence to higher spot prices, creating intense positive skew exactly when traditional portfolios suffer.
Trend following synergy
Commodity carry and time-series trend strategies become highly correlated during crises, making trend-following overlays particularly effective for capturing pro-cyclical commodity exposure.
Bottom Line
Investors must immediately stress-test portfolios for sustained stagflation by increasing allocations to commodity trend strategies and FX carry trades, while reducing reliance on equity-bond correlations that historically fail during inflationary regimes.
More from Excess Returns
View all
We Asked Ben Carlson How an 86% Crash Still Led to 8% Annual Returns
Financial expert Ben Carlson explains that successful long-term investing requires accepting unavoidable risk, resisting action bias during volatility, and understanding that even an 86% crash in 1929 couldn't prevent 8% annual returns for patient investors who avoided panic selling.
He Predicted the AI Bubble in 2023 | Doug Clinton and Gene Munster on Why We're Still in 1996
Deep Water Asset Management's Doug Clinton and Gene Munster argue AI remains in its 1996-era infancy with years of growth ahead before any bubble peak, as enterprise adoption explodes with coding agents driving unprecedented demand while threatening severe short-term disruption to knowledge workers who fail to adapt.
He Invested Through Five Bubbles. He Wrote the Book on Them | What We Learned This Week
Legendary bubble investor Jeremy Grantham and macro strategist Andy Constant join the podcast to explain why mega-cap tech has defied historical mean reversion through regulatory tolerance of monopolies, while detailing the three-phase lifecycle of financial bubbles from innovation through escalation to peak.
We Asked Jeremy Grantham Why AI Won’t Boost Profits — and What It Will Do Instead
Legendary investor Jeremy Grantham argues that AI will ultimately become a commoditized cost of doing business rather than a driver of permanently higher corporate profits, while defending his reputation as a selective "perma bear" who believes mean reversion remains the dominant force in markets despite recent monopoly distortions.