This Is How The Next Great Depression Starts Warns Economist | George Selgin
TL;DR
Economist George Selgin argues the Great Depression required a catastrophic convergence of banking collapses, gold standard failures, and protectionist tariffs—a 'perfect storm' unlikely to repeat today due to stronger financial safeguards and learned policy lessons, though current regime uncertainty and oil-driven inflation pose serious stagflation risks.
🏛️ The Perfect Storm of the 1930s 3 insights
Fragile gold standard unraveling
The interwar gold standard was designed to economize on gold but collapsed when international cooperation broke down in the late 1920s, triggering a global contraction in money supplies and credit.
US banking system collapse
The weak pre-FDIC system saw thousands of banks fail annually throughout the 1920s, accelerating dramatically after the 1929 crash and compounding the monetary contraction.
Tariffs aggravated existing crises
While Smoot-Hawley and retaliatory tariffs worsened the downturn, they aggravated existing monetary and banking failures rather than single-handedly causing the depression.
📈 What Actually Ended the Depression 3 insights
New Deal programs largely failed
The National Recovery Administration's price-fixing cartels worsened unemployment, and the Federal Reserve failed to offset monetary collapse during the 1930s.
WWII provided only temporary relief
Military enlistment and war production temporarily masked unemployment, but experts feared the depression would return when troops demobilized and defense orders dried up in 1945.
Post-war private investment boom
Real recovery began when regime uncertainty ended, anti-business policies were repealed, and private investment 'took off like a rocket' after 1945 without massive fiscal stimulus.
⚠️ Modern Economic Risks 3 insights
Regime uncertainty suppresses growth
Current tariff wars and geopolitical conflict in Iran create policy uncertainty that drags on hiring and investment, mirroring the New Deal era's business hesitation.
Oil shocks threaten stagflation
With oil near $100 per barrel and potential Strait of Hormuz closures, inflation will likely exceed the Fed's 2% target through supply constraints that monetary policy cannot easily fix.
Fed faces impossible trade-off
Attempting to fight supply-driven inflation through rate hikes could easily trigger recession, repeating the Federal Reserve's error during the 2008 oil shock.
Bottom Line
Sustainable recovery requires stable policies that encourage private investment rather than aggressive government intervention, while the Federal Reserve must avoid triggering recession by tightening into supply-driven inflation caused by oil shocks.
More from The David Lin Report
View all
Credit Collapse Warning: Rick Rule Reveals 'The One Thing That Really Scares Me'
Rick Rule warns that high-yield bond ETFs pose systemic liquidity risks that could trigger a 2008-style crisis, while highlighting rare buying opportunities in oversold junior miners, community banks trading below book value, and Canadian oil & gas as he expects economic weakness in the second half of 2026.
50% Crash Or Violent Rally? CEO Reveals Gold's Breakout | Dan Wilton
First Mining Gold CEO Dan Wilton explains how regulatory milestones and First Nations agreements drove a 70% stock surge despite falling gold prices, while outlining a strategy to fund the $1.1 billion Spring Pole project without excessive shareholder dilution.
Biggest Crash Since 1929: 90% Collapse Starting, Warns Economist | Harry Dent
Economist Harry Dent warns that a 16-year 'Frankenstein bubble' artificially inflated by $31 trillion in government stimulus is about to burst, predicting the S&P 500 will crash 50% within three months and ultimately decline 80-90% over two years—the worst collapse since 1929.
20% Nasdaq Crash Just Months Away; Investor Reveals Top Shorts | David Woo
David Woo forecasts a 20% Nasdaq crash within months as the AI bubble bursts from regulatory restrictions on frontier models and competitive commoditization, while arguing the recent soft jobs data masks an economy temporarily propped up by tax-driven capex incentives.