The Young Economic Populists Reshaping the Left
TL;DR
College graduates have shifted from reliable Republican voters in the 1980s to a Democratic-leaning bloc embracing economic populism, driven by skyrocketing debt, underemployment, and the perceived betrayal of the 'college promise' that failed to deliver upper-middle-class prosperity.
🗳️ The Political Reversal 2 insights
From Republican stronghold to progressive base
In the 1980s, college graduates voted Republican by double-digit margins and favored smaller government, but by the most recent election they supported Kamala Harris over Donald Trump by roughly 15 points, aligning with working-class economic positions.
Shattered class identity
Previously viewing themselves as 'management adjacent' destined for affluence, graduates now identify with exploited workers after decades of wage stagnation and precarious employment failed to deliver promised prosperity.
💸 The Debt Trap and Degree Dilution 2 insights
Mass expansion lowered degree value
As college enrollment tripled from 10% of Americans in 1970 to 30% by 2010, the market flooded with for-profit and non-competitive public universities that diluted the economic value of degrees while Congress repeatedly raised student loan limits.
Debt doubled without proportional returns
Average student debt roughly doubled between the early 1990s and 2020, with parents increasingly borrowing to cover gaps, yet graduates from open-admission public universities often found the costs outweighed the career benefits.
⚡ The 2008 Crisis and Populist Awakening 2 insights
Bailouts exposed a 'two-tier' system
The 2008 financial crisis left recent graduates facing the highest unemployment in decades while watching the government rescue Wall Street banks, creating a perception that the ultra-wealthy received help while indebted graduates were left behind.
Occupy Wall Street as political catalyst
Approximately three-quarters of Occupy Wall Street protesters held college degrees, using the 2011 movement to elevate student debt forgiveness and transform their political identity from future elites to members of the exploited '99%.'
🏢 Consolidation and Worker Power 2 insights
Mergers reduced worker agency
Post-recession consolidation across tech, healthcare, and retail reduced employment options and worker power, as acquisitions like Facebook buying Instagram created bureaucratic environments that left educated professionals feeling alienated.
Regulatory trade-offs hurt workers
While the Affordable Care Act expanded healthcare access, it accelerated hospital consolidation by shifting financial risk to providers, inadvertently making the industry worse for workers even as it helped patients.
Bottom Line
The leftward shift of college graduates represents a permanent political realignment driven by economic precarity rather than cultural trends, meaning progressive candidates must address structural issues like student debt and corporate consolidation to maintain support from this crucial voting bloc.
More from New York Times Podcasts
View all
The Implosion of Graham Platner
Democratic Senate candidate Graham Platner faces imminent campaign collapse following explosive sexual assault allegations, triggering a chaotic scramble to replace him on the Maine ballot by a July 13 deadline while exposing deep fissures between the party's progressive and establishment wings.
Ask Me About My Dead Son
Bereaved mother Susie Shaw shares a roadmap for supporting parents who have lost a child, explaining that asking specific, curious questions about the deceased—rather than offering generic condolences—provides the greatest comfort and keeps their memory present.
The Light Switches That Changed My Life
Wirecutter editors demonstrate how installing basic smart light switches transformed daily life for accessibility editor Claire Pearlman, who uses a wheelchair, eliminating her dependence on caregivers for lighting control and reducing mental load through voice-activated home automation.
Jill Lepore on What to Read This Fourth of July
Historian Jill Lepore examines America's upcoming 250th anniversary as a moment of profound political tension, comparing today's divisions to the cynical, protest-filled Bicentennial of 1976 while advocating for constitutional deliberation and collective reading as acts of civic participation.