Jill Lepore on What to Read This Fourth of July
TL;DR
Historian Jill Lepore examines America's upcoming 250th anniversary as a moment of profound political tension, comparing today's divisions to the cynical, protest-filled Bicentennial of 1976 while advocating for constitutional deliberation and collective reading as acts of civic participation.
🇺🇸 Historical Reflections on National Milestones 3 insights
The 1976 Bicentennial was defined by cynicism and protest
The 200th anniversary occurred amid Watergate and Vietnam, featuring excessive commercialization ('Bicentennial schlock') alongside protests by Vietnam veterans, gay rights activists, and ERA supporters who nearly disrupted the Boston Tea Party reenactment.
The 250th anniversary feels like a pulled bowstring
A woman from New Orleans described the current national mood as an arrow drawn back at 'tremendous tension,' suggesting the semi-quincentennial represents a pivotal moment before potential release or transformation.
Dissent is the truest form of patriotism
Lepore argues that allowing 'unfettered dissent' during national celebrations represents the best of American democracy, as seen in 1976 when diverse protesters claimed their place in the nation's story.
📜 Constitutional Futures and Civic Repair 3 insights
America has abandoned the philosophy of amendment
The U.S. has not meaningfully amended the federal Constitution since 1971, abandoning the founders' vision that constitutional change was essential for justice, prosperity, and updating the nation's governing framework.
A new constitution may eventually be necessary
Lepore predicts America will eventually require an entirely new constitution, though this would first require rebuilding civic capacity through state-level citizens' assemblies and deliberative practices that restore the ability to debate collectively.
Milestones should prompt future-oriented deliberation
Rather than merely celebrating the past, the 250th anniversary should spark conversations about constitutional amendment as a tool for making 'repairs' and creating a more just future.
📚 Reading Recommendations for the Moment 3 insights
Pauline Maier's 'American Scripture'
This readable history offers the definitive account of the Declaration of Independence's creation and significance.
Mark Stein's 'Bicentennial'
Stein examines the 1976 Philadelphia celebrations through the intersecting lenses of urban renewal politics and the gay rights movement, illuminating the racial and class conflicts underlying the festivities.
Ali Smith's dystopian novel 'Glyph'
This 2024 novel depicts a surveillance state where 'unverified' citizens are hunted, capturing the emotional reality of modern political terror more accurately than recent history books despite being set in a near-future Britain.
Bottom Line
Americans should observe the 250th anniversary by reading the Declaration of Independence aloud with diverse groups—particularly through initiatives like Monticello's Declaration Book Club—to foster civic deliberation about constitutional amendment and the nation's future rather than merely celebrating the past.
More from New York Times Podcasts
View all
The Fallout of Massive Earthquakes for Venezuela — and the U.S.
Twin earthquakes in Venezuela exposed catastrophic institutional failure where years of politically-motivated shoddy construction and a recent US-backed governmental transition left the state incapable of coordinating rescue efforts, forcing civilians to search for survivors amid collapsed social housing while Washington and local officials struggled with bureaucratic chaos.
Eddie Huang Drops the Tough Guy Act
Author and chef Eddie Huang explores how childhood bullying and systemic stereotypes forced him to adopt a 'tough guy' persona to survive, and how he's worked to unlearn that armor to find authentic connection and vulnerability in relationships.
The Secrets to Being Stink-Free
This podcast episode explains the crucial differences between deodorants and antiperspirants—where the latter uses aluminum compounds to block sweat ducts—and reveals why finding the right product requires extensive personal testing due to unique body chemistry and bacterial flora.
Why Everyone Cares About This World Cup
The 2026 World Cup has become an unprecedented cultural experiment, bringing 48 teams and their fans to small-town America and creating surprising connections between international visitors and local communities, while also exposing the complex political tensions within immigrant diasporas.