The Doomsday AI Article That Sparked a Panic | Last Call
TL;DR
Hosts Matt and Jack, along with options strategist Brent Kachuba, analyze the market panic sparked by a viral AI doomsday article (the 'Catrini piece'), explaining why this 'manufactured story from the future' served as a contrarian sentiment indicator for software stocks while emphasizing the need for probabilistic scenario planning over binary AI predictions.
📉 The Viral AI Doomsday Narrative 3 insights
Fiction treated as forecast
The 'Catrini' article explicitly labeled itself as a 'manufactured story from the future' and science fiction bear case exercise, yet triggered formal responses from Fed Governor Waller, Citadel, and Jeremy Seagull.
Article marked a potential bottom
The piece published precisely as software stocks (IGV) hit key technical support levels, suggesting the narrative panic may have marked a local sentiment extreme rather than the start of a crash.
Range-bound market reality
Despite the doomsday narrative, the S&P 500 has traded sideways between 6,800-7,000 for months with no actual fear-driven put buying detected in options data.
📊 Options Market Insights 3 insights
Put/call ratio contrarian signal
Viral charts highlighting extreme put/call ratios in software stocks actually coincided with historical market bottoms, not tops, indicating capitulation rather than impending doom.
Differentiation within software
Options pricing reveals a bifurcated market where names like Adobe and Autodesk show varying volatility profiles, contradicting the idea of blanket AI-driven software destruction.
Corporate buybacks contradict doom
Salesforce announced a $50 billion buyback program, suggesting major software companies do not view AI as an immediate existential threat requiring defensive cash hoarding.
🎯 Framework for AI Uncertainty 3 insights
Probabilistic scenario planning
Investors must map multiple base, bull, and bear cases rather than betting on single outcomes, as AI represents unprecedented uncertainty regarding labor replacement versus enhancement.
Inflationary buildout, disinflationary outcome
Current AI infrastructure spending creates near-term inflationary pressure, but successful deployment could trigger long-term 'Ghost GDP' deflation as productivity potentially soars.
Risk means more things can happen
Extreme bear cases serve as valuable stress tests for portfolio construction but should not drive tactical positioning given the wide distribution of potential AI outcomes.
Bottom Line
Use extreme AI doomsday scenarios as risk management tools to stress-test portfolio resilience, but maintain exposure across a range of probabilistic outcomes rather than positioning for binary predictions.
More from Excess Returns
View all
We Asked an Options Expert Why War and Oil Haven’t Broken This Market — and Which Signal Could
Options expert Brent explains why escalating Middle East tensions and $115 oil haven't derailed the market's AI-driven meltup, citing record call option volumes, the removal of pattern day trading rules, and the market's willingness to ignore short-term macro risks for long-term capex growth.
We Asked a $4.5B Quant Manager Why the S&P 500 Is Just 46 Stocks — and Why Small Caps Aren't Dead
A Bridgeway quant manager reveals that only 46 S&P 500 stocks currently drive index returns, while new research shows that filtering for persistently small companies (not just current small-cap status) revives the size premium, and explains why multifactor strategies with rigorous human oversight outperform single-factor smart beta approaches.
We Asked Jim Paulsen What Happens When 87% of the Economy Can No Longer Be Ignored
Jim Paulsen argues that policy officials are fixated on inflation and the tech sector while ignoring a weak '90% of the economy' nearing stall speed. He predicts the Fed will be forced to pivot toward easing this year as growth concerns overtake inflation fears, driving a rotation from mega-cap tech into small caps, value, and international equities while bond yields fall.
The Last Moat | Chris Mayer and Ian Cassel on the Stock Picking Edge AI Can’t Replicate
As AI commoditizes financial data and quantitative analysis, the only durable edge left for stock pickers is physical "presence"—building deep, long-term relationships with management teams and maintaining multi-year time horizons that algorithms and passive screens cannot replicate.