Jake Sullivan: 'Hard to see' what U.S. has gained in Iran
TL;DR
Former National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan argues that the Trump administration's military conflict with Iran has backfired strategically, leaving the US worse off with a closed Strait of Hormuz and emboldened hardliners, while warning that proposed military intervention in Cuba fails essential criteria for justified force.
🇮🇷 Iran: A Strategic Setback 3 insights
Military action produced net losses
The Strait of Hormuz is now closed, hardliners are entrenched, and a nuclear deal is further away than before the strikes, despite Iran having offered more forward-leaning proposals prior to the bombing.
Netanyahu's unusual influence
The Israeli Prime Minister exercised extraordinary sway by personally presenting the war case in the White House situation room, though Trump now appears focused on extricating himself rather than following Israeli preferences.
Accelerated nuclear weapons risk
The killing of Supreme Leader Khamenei—who maintained a policy of nuclear threshold capability without actual bomb construction—removes a restraining voice and empowers Revolutionary Guard hardliners who have long advocated for pursuing weapons.
⚔️ Military Intervention Criteria 3 insights
Three-pronged test for force
Sullivan outlined strict criteria for US military action: a direct threat to the US, military force being the only solution, and informed consent of the American people—all absent regarding Cuba.
Legacy-driven foreign policy
Sullivan suggests Trump's sudden interest in Cuba reflects second-term focus on legacy and historical comparisons to figures like Napoleon, contradicting his reelection campaign arguments.
Rubio's dual-role influence
Secretary of State Marco Rubio's personal passion for Cuba policy, combined with his dual National Security Advisor role, drives the administration's strategy of using Venezuela as an 'opening act' to cut energy flows to Cuba before targeting the island.
🏛️ Post-Government Perspective 2 insights
Persistent crisis wiring
After 16 months out of government, Sullivan describes automatic physiological responses to global crises that make relaxation impossible, requiring an adjustment period he estimates may take years rather than months.
Open-source intelligence shift
Without the President's Daily Brief, Sullivan now consumes dozens of news websites, specialized substacks, and trade press covering AI and semiconductors to maintain situational awareness.
🤝 Diplomatic Solutions 2 insights
No military solution for Iran
Sullivan cites senior military officials confirming no 'finish the job' military option exists, advocating instead for a thin near-term deal to prevent further escalation and buy time for strategic regrouping.
Ukraine requires negotiation
Sullivan reaffirms that the Ukraine war will not end on the battlefield but only through diplomatic agreement, consistent with his previous assessments that territorial solutions are impossible through combat.
Bottom Line
Military interventions without clear strategic objectives or viable exit strategies—like the current Iran conflict or proposed Cuba actions—tend to worsen American strategic positioning, making even imperfect diplomatic deals preferable to escalating into dead-end conflicts.
More from How I Built This (NPR)
View all
The radical pastor Hegseth invited to preach at the Pentagon shares his vision for America | NPR
Pastor Doug Wilson, a self-described Christian nationalist who preached at the Pentagon at Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's invitation, details his vision for transforming America into a Christian theocracy through incremental legal changes while maintaining influence through classical education networks and high-level political access.
Ukraine latest / Limits of military might / Can major powers regain dominance?
Ukraine's innovative use of air, sea, and ground drones has allowed it to resist Russia's larger military force, creating a new asymmetric warfare model where smaller powers can effectively challenge superpowers—a pattern also seen in Iran's standoff with the U.S. in the Strait of Hormuz.
How far should the government go to protect America?
Former Bush and Obama administration officials reflect on the legal and moral challenges of crafting America's counterterrorism response to 9/11, revealing how emergency powers granted in 2001 continue to shape presidential authority and civil liberties debates today.
Starmer’s successor / Reset on UK-US relationship? / Strait latest
Amid historic political instability that has seen seven prime ministers in ten years since Brexit, Keir Starmer resigned due to record-low approval ratings, positioning Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham as his likely successor while the UK navigates strained US relations and deepens its military commitment to Ukraine.