How Iranians See the War
TL;DR
Despite President Trump's calls for Iranians to overthrow their government during US-Israeli bombing campaigns, Iranians remained largely paralyzed by communication blackouts, regime oppression, and deep-seated trauma from decades of violent crackdowns on protesters.
📵 Communication Blackout and Initial Reactions 3 insights
99% internet blackout isolates population
The Iranian government imposed a near-total internet blackout that left 99% of citizens offline, preventing communication with the outside world and forcing journalists to rely on the 1% with VPNs or satellite connections.
Mixed emotions on Supreme Leader's death
Anti-regime Iranians celebrated Ayatollah Khamenei's assassination and chanted victory slogans, while regime supporters grieved or pledged to fight American and Israeli invaders.
Trump's call to action goes unanswered
Despite the president's video urging Iranians to "seize control," most stayed off the streets due to immediate survival concerns and knowledge that pro-regime forces were shooting civilians.
🪧 From Protest to Desperation 3 insights
Childhood indoctrination meets Western culture
A dissident identified as C described growing up with anti-American chants in mosques while secretly watching Western films and questioning why Iran hated cultures that seemed similar to his own.
Massacre of 7,000 protesters destroys hope
After security forces killed an estimated 7,000 demonstrators during January protests—shooting many in the head and eyes—C concluded that peaceful protest was futile and war became the "only solution."
War divides families
Stranded in Europe, C found his wife blamed him and other protesters for civilian suffering, telling him "this is on you that people are suffering from war," illustrating deep internal divisions.
🛣️ Generational Divides and Divergent Loyalties 2 insights
Child of revolutionaries becomes refugee
F, a feminist translator and musician, fled to Turkey after the bombing triggered childhood trauma from the Iran-Iraq war, despite her parents having been ideological supporters of the 1979 revolution.
Regime support shaped by family history
F's upbringing included Quran recitation and revolutionary anniversaries, contrasting with C's experience to show how family background creates vastly different perspectives on foreign intervention.
💔 Civilian Cost and Uncertain Future 3 insights
Economic devastation and civilian casualties
Bombing destroyed hospitals, schools, and factories, leaving over 1,700 civilians dead and more than one million Iranians unemployed.
Threats alienate potential allies
Trump's shift from promising liberation to threatening to "annihilate" Iranian civilization caused widespread fear that the US might use nuclear weapons, undermining support among regime opponents.
Ceasefire leaves country in limbo
With the regime still standing after the ceasefire, dissidents like C lost faith in protest while remaining trapped in exile, unsure what Iran they would return to or how change might finally occur.
Bottom Line
Decades of brutal regime crackdowns have convinced many Iranian dissidents that peaceful protest is deadly and futile, yet military intervention has only deepened civilian suffering and internal blame without delivering the political change advocates risked their lives to achieve.
More from New York Times Podcasts
View all
Inside the Five Days That Remade the Supreme Court
A New York Times investigation reveals that the Supreme Court's controversial 'shadow docket' originated in a pivotal five-day period in 2016, when Chief Justice Roberts successfully pushed to block Obama's Clean Power Plan through emergency orders, fundamentally altering how the court handles urgent cases with minimal deliberation.
The Time Loop Book Series You Should Be Reading
New York Times book critics discuss Danish author SV Bala's seven-volume novel 'On the Calculation of Volume,' which follows a woman trapped reliving November 18th, examining its hypnotic diary-style narrative, philosophical meditations on consumption, and deliberate rejection of time-loop genre conventions.
Trump vs. the Pope
Pope Leo XIV and President Trump are engaged in an unprecedented public feud over the morality of the war with Iran, with the traditionally mild-mannered Pope forcefully condemning Trump's threats to annihilate civilization while Trump has attacked the Pope as a 'tool of the radical left' and posted an AI image of himself as a Christ-like figure, forcing American Catholics including VP JD Vance to choose between religious authority and political loyalty.
The Only 3 Knives You Actually Need in Your Kitchen
Professional kitchen experts confirm you only need three specific knives to handle virtually any cooking task, and investing in individual high-quality blades tailored to your hand size beats buying expensive pre-made sets.