Gold: Dubious Speculation
TL;DR
Silver has likely topped for the year with a 37% drawdown, while gold—currently down only 13%—has a 60-65% probability of hitting new all-time highs before stocks recover, based on historical gold-silver ratio cycles and sequential topping patterns seen in 1973 and 2011.
⚖️ Gold-Silver Ratio Dynamics 3 insights
Silver's parabolic rally has collapsed 37% from highs
Silver has entered a blowoff top correction while gold has pulled back only 13%, signaling a major divergence in precious metals performance.
Ratio hit generational floor seen in 1987, 1998, 2006, 2011
The gold-silver ratio bottomed at levels historically preceding multi-year periods of gold outperformance.
Historical recoveries last 2.5 to 9 years after such ratio lows
Following previous ratio bottoms, gold outperformed silver for 30 to 107 months, suggesting a prolonged shift in relative strength.
⏰ Historical Topping Sequences 3 insights
Silver historically peaks months before gold tops
In 1973 and 2011, silver reached euphoric highs in February and April respectively, while gold continued rising until December and September.
Gold likely to hit new ATH while silver consolidates years
Cowen estimates a 60-65% probability gold reaches new all-time highs this year, whereas silver faces a 75% chance of having already topped for 2026.
Gold typically reaches new highs faster than S&P after recessions
During the 1970s bull market, gold returned to all-time highs by 1978 while the S&P 500 did not recover until 1980.
⚠️ Recession Risk & Macro Outlook 3 insights
US recession likely when Treasury yield curve uninverts
Historical data shows recessions follow yield curve uninversions, which would temporarily pressure both metals but hit equities harder.
Current S&P/Gold ratio breakdown mirrors only 1973 and 2008
The relative valuation of stocks to gold has only broken down from current levels twice in history, both preceding major economic shifts.
Gold holds up better than equities and recovers to ATH faster
During past recessions, metals declined less severely than stocks and reclaimed all-time highs well before equity markets.
🛡️ Tactical Allocation Strategy 3 insights
Converting silver to gold reduces downside while maintaining upside
Rotating from silver to gold preserves exposure to the metals bull market while minimizing drawdown risk during silver's consolidation.
Silver shows 75% yearly top probability versus 35% for gold
The asymmetric risk profile favors gold, as even if both decline, silver would likely fall significantly further than gold.
Gold offers blue chip stability within the metals bull market
Positioning in gold provides relative safety during the expected 1-2 year digestion period for silver.
Bottom Line
Exchange silver positions for gold to capture potential new all-time highs while minimizing downside exposure during silver's prolonged consolidation and the approaching recession.
More from Benjamin Cowen
View all
Gold Drops Nearly 30%
Benjamin Cowen argues that despite gold's 20-30% drop from highs, the metal remains in a larger bull market that could extend into the 2030s, particularly as the S&P 500 has fallen 44% against gold since 2022 and historical patterns suggest gold recovers faster than equities after recessions.
NFA Live
Benjamin Cowen and guests analyze the Federal Reserve's policy paralysis between rising inflation and unemployment, alongside a shift in Bitcoin market dynamics as Satoshi-era whales begin taking profits after years of accumulation, signaling late business cycle conditions.
NFA Live! Bitcoin in 2026
The hosts analyze how escalating Middle East tensions are driving oil prices toward recession-threatening levels while crypto markets endure abysmal midterm-year bear sentiment, arguing that defensive positioning and realistic risk assessment outweigh blind optimism during volatile four-year cycle corrections.
Business Cycles Ends With Recessions
Benjamin Cowen argues that the U.S. is in a late business cycle environment using a custom macro indicator normalized by M2 money supply, suggesting a recession is likely within 2-3 years (possibly 2026), and warns that risk assets typically bottom before recessions are officially announced.