Apple at 50: the good and the bad | The Vergecast
TL;DR
On Apple's 50th anniversary, veteran analyst Jason Snell evaluates the company as being at peak hardware performance due to Apple Silicon and manufacturing excellence, but currently struggling through a 'butterfly keyboard era' of software design where aesthetic ambitions like liquid glass are undermining usability across platforms.
🏆 Hardware Manufacturing Excellence 3 insights
Apple Silicon drives unprecedented Mac success
Apple-designed chips (fabbed by TSMC) have driven Mac sales to 40-year highs and enabled aggressively priced products like the $599 MacBook Neo that wouldn't exist without custom silicon.
Manufacturing mastery under Tim Cook
Apple's rare insistence on custom fabrication techniques rather than off-the-shelf parts has resulted in hardware quality across iPhone, iPad, and Mac lineups that Snell considers 'never better' in the company's history.
Mac rescued from legacy neglect
After years of treating the Mac as a 'legacy product' during the 'iPad is the future' era, Apple has returned the Mac to priority status, steering out of the skid with coordinated hardware and chip design.
🐛 Software Usability Crisis 3 insights
The 'butterfly keyboard era' of interfaces
Current software prioritizes aesthetic 'liquid glass' design over daily usability, mirroring the 2010s hardware mistake where thinness was prioritized over the typing experience.
Liquid glass forced across inappropriate platforms
The interface paradigm designed for Vision Pro's augmented reality environment has been mechanically applied to iOS and macOS despite reducing usability on traditional flat-screen devices.
Repeat of historical design overreach
Apple is repeating the butterfly keyboard pattern where a solution created for one specific product (the 12-inch MacBook) was shoved into every product line regardless of fit.
🎨 Design Culture & Leadership 3 insights
Post-Jobs design imbalance persists
The post-Steve Jobs decision to retain Jony Ive at all costs gave design teams excessive power, creating a persistent cultural imbalance between visual aesthetics and engineering practicality.
Alan Dye's departure creates turning point
The surprise defection of software design head Alan Dye to Meta—after executives had approved his aesthetic-focused vision—opens opportunity for new leadership to rebalance software design with engineering needs.
Hardware-software disconnect exemplified by Touch Bar
The Touch Bar demonstrated Apple's broken process: hardware shipped with software that was never meaningfully updated throughout the product's entire lifecycle.
Bottom Line
While Apple currently manufactures the best hardware in its 50-year history, its software urgently needs to abandon the pursuit of aesthetic uniformity in favor of platform-appropriate usability as it enters its next era under new design leadership.
More from The Verge
View all
Apple's best product ever | The Vergecast
The Vergecast hosts analyze OpenAI's strategic pivot from consumer AI products to enterprise automation, highlighting the growing disconnect between the industry's 'super intelligence' marketing promises and its actual delivery of business software tools, while also revealing that their Apple product ranking suffered a bot attack attempting to manipulate iTunes to number one.
Meta's court losses could be just the beginning | The Vergecast
The hosts navigate the chaotic TSA airport crisis caused by DHS funding disputes while debuting The Verge's interactive Apple 50th anniversary product ranker, alongside discussions of AI's impact on the legal system and complex iMac hardware modifications.
Welp, I bought an iPhone again | The Vergecast
After months of testing flip phones, foldables, and Android devices to escape iPhone boredom, host David Pierce reluctantly purchased an iPhone 17, concluding that the excruciating friction of switching ecosystems outweighs the benefits of alternative hardware despite Android's superior spam filtering.
RIP Trifold | The Vergecast
OpenAI is retreating from consumer AI ambitions after failing to monetize ChatGPT, pivoting to enterprise customers amid growing evidence that the public—including Gen Z—views AI as a net negative, with industry leaders now blaming users instead of building products people actually want.