Will the Iran War Break MAGA? | Interesting Times with Ross Douthat
TL;DR
Despite Trump campaigning on ending endless wars, his second administration has become hawkish, launching wars with Iran and interventions in multiple countries, betraying the America First movement that helped elect him.
⚔️ Trump's Hawkish Turn 3 insights
Major policy reversal from campaign promises
Trump is now at war with Iran, backing Ukraine against Russia, and intervening in Venezuela and Nigeria despite promising to end endless wars.
Early restraint efforts were abandoned
The administration initially pursued diplomacy with Iran negotiations in April 2025 and Vance's confrontation with Zelensky, but quickly shifted to military action.
Presidential personality drives war decisions
Trump's impatience with diplomacy, agreeableness to hawks in his administration, and attraction to military strikes override restraint-oriented advisors.
🇺🇸 The America First Ideology 3 insights
Conservative anti-globalism defines the movement
The ideology combines skepticism of overseas empire, opposition to mass immigration, and rejection of free trade policies that don't serve national interests.
Historical precedent exists for restraint
Mills traces a Republican tradition from Eisenhower through Nixon that was internationalist but skeptical of military intervention, preferring diplomacy to warfare.
Public support exists but needs leadership
Opposition to interventions comes primarily from DC and New York elites, not grassroots protests, suggesting Americans would support restraint if explained properly.
📊 Political Dynamics and Support 3 insights
Republican voters follow Trump's lead
Overwhelming Republican support for the Iran war reflects partisan deference rather than genuine hawkish philosophy - they would likely support peace deals if Trump negotiated them.
European allies exploit Trump's hawkishness
German Chancellor Friedrich Merz immediately flew to DC when the Iran war started, supporting Trump on Iran to get him back on board with NATO and Ukraine.
Generational divide shapes foreign policy views
Older conservatives maintain stronger hawkish defaults from previous eras, while younger appointees were more aligned with restraint principles before being overruled.
Bottom Line
Trump's return to interventionist foreign policy represents a fundamental betrayal of the America First movement, driven more by his personality traits and elite pressure than genuine strategic thinking or voter demands.
More from Interesting Times with Ross Douthat
View all
White Identity Is Galvanizing the Right | Interesting Times with Ross Douthat
Claremont Institute senior fellow Jeremy Carl defends his State Department nomination and book "The Unprotected Class," arguing that disparate impact laws, mass immigration since 1965, and DEI initiatives have created systemic discrimination against white Americans—a condition he terms "cultural genocide"—while insisting he advocates civic nationalism rather than white nationalism.
The Democrats Could Still Screw This Up | Interesting Times With Ross Douthat
Despite being 'crushed' in 2024 with only 28% favorability, Democrats are regaining confidence due to Trump's perceived overreach on constitutional authority and tariffs, though deep internal conflicts over tactics, generational leadership, and divisive policy battles threaten recovery without a clear affirmative vision for the country.
NASA Wants What Musk Wants: Moon Bases and Mars Colonies | Interesting Times with Ross Douthat
NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman outlines a viable 10-year timeline for Mars missions contingent on sustained political will, while detailing how the Artemis program will transition from expensive test flights using legacy shuttle hardware to a permanent lunar base serving as a proving ground for deep space survival and resource extraction.
The Future Is Indian | Interesting Times with Ross Douthat
As India becomes the world's most populous nation and fastest-growing major economy, it is pursuing a complex multi-alignment strategy—balancing historic ties with Russia, new trade deals with Europe, and fraught relations with the U.S.—to secure recognition as a great power rather than dominance like China.