Why Energy Stocks Are Down When They Should Be Up with Bob Brackett | The Real Eisman Playbook Ep 60
TL;DR
Bob Brackett explains that despite Iran's historic blockage of the Strait of Hormuz removing 20% of global oil supply and triggering record inventory drains, energy stocks trade lower due to market hope for resolution and generalist investor apathy, creating a dangerous disconnect between surging fundamentals and depressed valuations.
🚢 The Unprecedented Supply Shock 3 insights
Iran closes Strait of Hormuz for first time ever
Iran has physically blocked the critical chokepoint with mines and vessel threats, halting 20% of global oil flows (10 million barrels/day), 20% of natural gas, and half of seaborne sulfur flows.
Inventory drainage hits record velocity
Commercial and strategic inventories are plummeting at rates never seen before, with approximately one billion barrels already drained from global stocks to compensate for the supply shortfall.
Disruption exceeds Russia-Ukraine war impact
The 10 million barrel/day shut-in dwarfs the 7 million barrel/day loss during the Russia-Ukraine invasion, yet oil prices peaked at only $115 versus $120 in 2022 despite the larger shock.
📉 The Market Disconnect 3 insights
Forward curve predicts price collapse
Despite spot prices near $90, the forward curve trades in steep backwardation with one-year-out contracts pricing oil in the $70s, implying markets expect a swift resolution.
Energy sector minimized in portfolios
With energy representing only 4% of the S&P 500, generalist portfolio managers focused on AI and tech disruption are treating the sector as a negligible allocation rather than analyzing the supply crisis.
Exxon defies earnings logic
Exxon shares outperformed in January-February on cyclical recovery hopes but have declined since the Hormuz crisis began, even though earnings models should show dramatically higher EBITDA at current oil prices.
💰 Structural Financial Tailwinds 3 insights
Massive operating leverage amplifies gains
Integrated oil companies operate with roughly 50% EBITDA margins, meaning a $30 increase in oil prices can nearly double EBITDA since production costs remain relatively fixed regardless of commodity prices.
Inventory refill creates synthetic demand
Replenishing the one billion barrels of depleted inventories will require years of additional buying, effectively boosting demand growth by an extra 1% annually just to restock storage.
Permanent risk premium now warranted
Iran has demonstrated the capability to close the strait at will, meaning even if reopened, a permanent geopolitical risk premium must be embedded in mid-cycle oil prices to reflect ongoing closure probabilities.
Bottom Line
Energy stocks are fundamentally mispriced because markets are extrapolating a return to $70 oil via the forward curve despite structural supply constraints, record inventory drainage, and demonstrated geopolitical risks that support sustained higher prices and massive cash generation.
More from Steve Eisman
View all
FICO’s Monopoly is Fading & Consumers Are the Winners w/ Kelsey Zhu | The Real Eisman Playbook Ep 59
FICO has increased credit score pricing from $0.60 to $10 per pull, sparking massive industry backlash and regulatory intervention. The FHFA is now dismantling FICO's decades-long regulatory monopoly by allowing mortgage lenders to use VantageScore 4.0 instead, creating competition that could significantly reduce costs for consumers.
Is a Market Melt-Up Coming? Why Tech & Semis Are Dominating Again | The Real Eisman Playbook Ep 58
Steve Eisman and Strategus analysts Chris Veron and Todd Son analyze the market's rapid recovery from March lows, noting that leadership remains concentrated in AI-driven semiconductors—which now comprise 17% of the S&P 500—while software languishes at generational lows and gold inexplicably trades like a risk asset rather than a safe haven.
Apollo's Private Credit Exposure: Chris Edson Weighs In | The Real Eisman Playbook Ep 57
Chris Edson, Apollo's Global Head of Originations, explains that while media focuses on $1-2 trillion direct lending risks (particularly AI disruption in software), Apollo maintains minimal exposure (~2% of AUM) due to value-oriented cash flow discipline; instead, they leverage 16 origination platforms to generate alpha for retirement services by capturing illiquidity premiums unavailable in public bond markets.
Is a Recession Coming? What 100+ Companies Are Telling Us | The Weekly Wrap
After analyzing earnings from over 100 companies across multiple sectors, Steve Eisman concludes that recession fears remain overblown with no imminent economic downturn visible in the data, despite specific stress in private credit, software, and airline sectors from Middle East conflict and oil price spikes.