What Do You Do When a Family Member Commits a Terrible Crime? | 'The Opinions' Podcast
TL;DR
Author Harriet Clark, whose mother served 37 years in prison for a deadly robbery, joins New York Times columnist M. Gesson—whose cousin is serving a 10-year sentence for plotting to kill his ex-wife—to discuss how families navigate relationships with incarcerated relatives who have committed serious crimes, arguing that maintaining parent-child connections serves children's wellbeing better than permanent removal.
👨👩👧 Children of Incarcerated Parents 3 insights
Children need connection to avoid black hole abandonment
Clark explains that when parents disappear into prison without maintained contact, children inherit the painful knowledge that they are 'leavable' and are left with mythic, unprocessable absences rather than real relationships.
Facilitated visits can preserve family bonds
During Clark's 37 years of visiting her mother, a children's center with crafts and games demonstrated that prison environments can be adapted to support child development rather than sever ties.
Collective reality normalizes the experience
Visiting rooms filled with other children facing similar circumstances help kids understand they are not alone, countering the isolation of having an incarcerated parent.
🚫 Flaws in Carceral Logic 3 insights
Absence often damages more than managed presence
Clark's limited contact with her father—due to family anger and harsh visiting conditions—left her feeling more abandoned and confused than her maintained relationship with her mother did.
Disconnection replicates prison's punitive architecture
When families cut ties completely, they replicate the carceral system's logic of removal rather than creating the 'companioned' support children need to process difficult realities.
Five million children face this reality
With five million American children experiencing parental incarceration, the choice between abandonment and maintained connection affects a significant demographic.
⚖️ Vengeance, Justice, and Moving Forward 3 insights
The legal system channels rather than contains vengeance
Gesson observed that prosecutors amplify vengeful impulses rather than mediating them, while Clark notes that survivor communities often pressure parole boards to deny release regardless of rehabilitation.
Safety and connection must coexist
Healing requires collectively figuring out how incarcerated parents can support their children while ensuring victims remain safe and feel secure after release.
Post-crime relationships require dignity and effort
Rather than 'letting sleeping dogs lie,' families must engage in the difficult, ongoing work of helping incarcerated relatives become the best parents possible while acknowledging the harm caused.
Bottom Line
Families should actively facilitate relationships between children and incarcerated parents through regular contact and emotional support, recognizing that maintained connection—not permanent removal—serves both child wellbeing and community healing while still requiring accountability for harm caused.
More from New York Times Podcasts
View all
Jill Lepore on What to Read This Fourth of July
Historian Jill Lepore examines America's upcoming 250th anniversary as a moment of profound political tension, comparing today's divisions to the cynical, protest-filled Bicentennial of 1976 while advocating for constitutional deliberation and collective reading as acts of civic participation.
The Fallout of Massive Earthquakes for Venezuela — and the U.S.
Twin earthquakes in Venezuela exposed catastrophic institutional failure where years of politically-motivated shoddy construction and a recent US-backed governmental transition left the state incapable of coordinating rescue efforts, forcing civilians to search for survivors amid collapsed social housing while Washington and local officials struggled with bureaucratic chaos.
Eddie Huang Drops the Tough Guy Act
Author and chef Eddie Huang explores how childhood bullying and systemic stereotypes forced him to adopt a 'tough guy' persona to survive, and how he's worked to unlearn that armor to find authentic connection and vulnerability in relationships.
The Secrets to Being Stink-Free
This podcast episode explains the crucial differences between deodorants and antiperspirants—where the latter uses aluminum compounds to block sweat ducts—and reveals why finding the right product requires extensive personal testing due to unique body chemistry and bacterial flora.