Trump’s Lonely War
TL;DR
As the U.S. wages war against Iran without consulting NATO allies, European nations are refusing to join offensive operations due to strategic skepticism and Iraq-era trauma, even as they are economically dragged into the conflict through skyrocketing energy costs and the blocked Strait of Hormuz.
💔 The Alliance Rupture 3 insights
Surprise Attack Without Consultation
The U.S. and Israel launched air strikes against Iran on February 28th without notifying European allies, compounding existing tensions from Trump's earlier tariff threats and comments about taking over Greenland.
Article 5 Rejection
European leaders argue NATO's mutual defense clause does not apply because the U.S. initiated hostilities rather than suffering an attack first.
Threats of Economic Retaliation
Trump has threatened to pull the U.S. out of NATO and cut trade with non-compliant nations, specifically targeting Spain and mocking UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer as 'no Winston Churchill.'
🛡️ Europe's Limited Military Role 3 insights
Defensive-Only Support
European nations permit overflight rights and defensive operations to protect their own regional bases from Iranian drones and missiles, but refuse to allow offensive strikes from European soil.
Base Access Denials
Spain explicitly denied U.S. requests to use its military bases, while the UK rejected using British facilities for offensive operations despite long-standing security agreements.
Emboldened by Court Ruling
European allies have grown slightly bolder in resisting Trump's demands following a Supreme Court ruling that undermined the legality of his tariff authorities.
🎭 Strategic Skepticism and Historical Trauma 3 insights
Doubts on Nuclear Strategy
European leaders are skeptical that military strikes can destroy Iran's deeply buried highly enriched uranium stockpiles, viewing the strategy as unlikely to eliminate the nuclear threat.
Iraq and Afghanistan Scars
The specter of failed interventions in Iraq—which poisoned Tony Blair's legacy—and Afghanistan—a 20-year quagmire ending in Taliban victory—makes European leaders deeply wary of another Middle East war.
Limited Naval Options
While Europe possesses mine-sweeping capabilities for the Strait of Hormuz, leaders fear sending frigates into an active conflict would create vulnerable targets for Iranian missiles without guaranteeing safe passage.
⛽ Economic Entanglement 3 insights
Energy Price Shock
The Strait of Hormuz closure has sent European energy costs soaring, with German diesel exceeding $9 per gallon and governments facing pressure for costly consumer bailouts.
Inescapable Economic War
Despite refusing military involvement, Europe cannot avoid the economic fallout since roughly one-fifth of its oil and gas flows through the blocked waterway.
Ukraine Security Dilemma
European leaders balance defiance against fears that Trump will retaliate by withdrawing U.S. support for Ukraine, which remains a critical security priority for the continent.
Bottom Line
European allies will likely maintain a defensive-only posture and refuse offensive operations against Iran due to fundamental strategic disagreement and Iraq-era trauma, accepting severe economic pain over military entanglement.
More from New York Times Podcasts
View all
The Beginner's Guide to Car Camping
Wirecutter experts break down car camping as the most accessible entry point to outdoor sleeping, emphasizing that unlike backpacking, it's about maximizing comfort rather than minimizing gear. Staff writer Trey French shares essential investments for beginners, focusing on sleep quality, weather protection, and the freedom to bring creature comforts since your car does the heavy lifting.
My Husband’s Breakdown Was My Breakthrough
Stephanie Gunning recounts meeting her husband Jonathan at a camping store in 2000, reconnecting after 9/11, and navigating his depression after he disclosed his mental health struggles on their fourth date, revealing how early intimacy through vulnerability shaped their marriage.
What Do You Do When a Family Member Commits a Terrible Crime? | 'The Opinions' Podcast
Author Harriet Clark, whose mother served 37 years in prison for a deadly robbery, joins New York Times columnist M. Gesson—whose cousin is serving a 10-year sentence for plotting to kill his ex-wife—to discuss how families navigate relationships with incarcerated relatives who have committed serious crimes, arguing that maintaining parent-child connections serves children's wellbeing better than permanent removal.
The Supreme Court Takes On Birthright Citizenship
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments on President Trump's executive order to end birthright citizenship, with justices from across the ideological spectrum expressing skepticism toward the administration's novel interpretation of the 14th Amendment's 'subject to the jurisdiction thereof' clause.