Tinned Fish is Finally Having the Moment It Deserves
TL;DR
Tinned fish has transformed from pantry staple into a luxury food trend in the US, driven by pandemic pantry stocking and TikTok aesthetics. After testing over 100 cans, Wirecutter recommends starting with mild trout or salmon before advancing to oily sardines or texturally challenging mollusks, with premium prices reflecting artisanal hand-packing methods.
📈 The Tinned Fish Renaissance 2 insights
Pandemic and TikTok drove US popularity
Tinned fish exploded in America during the pandemic due to shelf-stable pantry appeal and social media aesthetics, despite being a longstanding bar culture staple in Spain and Portugal.
Positioned as luxury gifting item
Modern tinned fish is marketed as a premium delicacy with beautiful packaging, often compared to caviar and marketed for dinner party spreads rather than everyday lunch.
🐟 Navigating Categories by Experience Level 3 insights
Beginners should choose trout, tuna, or salmon
These options feature mild flavors and clean fillets rather than whole fish, making them less oily and visually approachable for newcomers compared to sardines.
Sardines and mackerel offer stronger flavors
These oilier varieties contain whole fish with bones and some organs, delivering more intense fish flavor for those ready to advance beyond mild fillets.
Mollusks present textural and visual challenges
Octopus, squid, mussels, and clams can be chewy and visually intimidating, while cod liver—though unappealing in appearance—tastes surprisingly like 'anchovies and butter'.
💰 Quality Justifies Premium Pricing 2 insights
Hand-packing drives $6 to $30+ price tags
Unlike mass-produced canned tuna, luxury tinned fish comes from small-production canneries where workers manually cut and arrange fish, sometimes wrapping cans in paper by hand.
Visual appeal matters for serving
Many premium cans are designed to be opened and served directly as 'silver jewels' for aesthetic appeal, though some like cod liver should be decanted due to unappealing visuals.
🍋 Serving and Pairing Strategies 2 insights
Add freshness to counter preserved texture
Balance the preserved nature of canned fish with fresh chopped herbs, lemon wedges, or hot sauce to introduce brightness and textural contrast.
Simple crackers and bread work perfectly
Saltines and sliced bread are perfectly acceptable vehicles, while pickled peppers and olives provide acidic balance; avoid mixing fish with cheese on the same board.
Bottom Line
Start with mild trout or salmon served with lemon and herbs on crackers or bread to ease into tinned fish, then explore oilier varieties as your palate adjusts.
More from New York Times Podcasts
View all
Jill Lepore on What to Read This Fourth of July
Historian Jill Lepore examines America's upcoming 250th anniversary as a moment of profound political tension, comparing today's divisions to the cynical, protest-filled Bicentennial of 1976 while advocating for constitutional deliberation and collective reading as acts of civic participation.
The Fallout of Massive Earthquakes for Venezuela — and the U.S.
Twin earthquakes in Venezuela exposed catastrophic institutional failure where years of politically-motivated shoddy construction and a recent US-backed governmental transition left the state incapable of coordinating rescue efforts, forcing civilians to search for survivors amid collapsed social housing while Washington and local officials struggled with bureaucratic chaos.
Eddie Huang Drops the Tough Guy Act
Author and chef Eddie Huang explores how childhood bullying and systemic stereotypes forced him to adopt a 'tough guy' persona to survive, and how he's worked to unlearn that armor to find authentic connection and vulnerability in relationships.
The Secrets to Being Stink-Free
This podcast episode explains the crucial differences between deodorants and antiperspirants—where the latter uses aluminum compounds to block sweat ducts—and reveals why finding the right product requires extensive personal testing due to unique body chemistry and bacterial flora.