They are history’s geniuses. But were they any good at investing? | The Story of Money Podcast
TL;DR
Despite possessing world-changing intellect and political genius, historical figures like Isaac Newton and Winston Churchill proved terrible investors, destroyed by the same emotional pitfalls—FOMO, overtrading, and leverage—that plague modern retail traders.
🧠 The Intelligence Trap 3 insights
Genius doesn't guarantee market returns
Finance firms recruit elite physicists and mathematicians assuming IQ correlates with alpha, but history shows intellectual brilliance often coexists with disastrous financial decision-making.
Newton's South Sea Bubble catastrophe
After cashing out near the peak for a £1.2 billion equivalent gain, Newton succumbed to FOMO and reinvested at the absolute top, losing 40% of his fortune.
The madness of crowds over calculus
Despite inventing calculus and mastering celestial mechanics, Newton admitted he could calculate planetary orbits but not human irrationality.
📉 Churchill's Leveraged Gambling 3 insights
Journalistic wealth fueled speculation
Churchill earned modern equivalent of £480,000 per article and £80 million book advances, providing capital for reckless trading during his 1929 US book tour.
Accidental margin trading disaster
Churchill discovered margin trading without understanding the risks, executing £80 million equivalent in turnover over nine days and losing his entire advance through speculation rather than the market crash.
Citadel-level turnover, retail-level results
His trading frequency rivaled modern high-frequency shops, but excessive leverage and lack of discipline completely wiped out his multi-million pound income.
💰 Measuring Historical Wealth 2 insights
GDP adjustment reveals true scale
While inflation calculators show Newton's £20,000 as £3.6 million today, GDP-adjusted figures better capture his actual economic power at approximately £1.2 billion.
Dynastic purchasing power
Measuring wealth against contemporary economic output rather than consumer baskets shows these figures held billionaire-level status comparable to modern ultra-high-net-worth individuals.
Bottom Line
Emotional discipline and risk management consistently outperform raw intelligence in investing; if geniuses like Newton and Churchill couldn't time markets or resist leverage, average investors should focus on boring, diversified strategies rather than trying to outsmart crowds.
More from Financial Times
View all
India and the true cost of coal | FT Film
Despite powering 75% of India's electricity and supporting 20 million livelihoods, coal imposes a devastating toll of 1.5 million pollution-related deaths annually, forcing the world's fastest-growing economy to balance energy security with its 2070 net-zero pledge through a complex, decades-long transition.
More in News
View all
Venture capital legend, Bill Gurley.
Venture capitalist Bill Gurley argues that chasing "fascination"—not just passion—drives outsized career success, as those endlessly curious about their field accumulate deeper expertise and move faster, especially in the AI era. Drawing from his book "Running Down a Dream," he explains how to avoid climbing the wrong ladder through tactical career experiments and peer co-learning.
LIVE: Trump speaks after rushed from White House correspondents' dinner
President Trump addressed the media after being evacuated from the White House Correspondents' Dinner due to an armed security breach, praising Secret Service for swiftly subduing the suspect and announcing the event will be rescheduled within 30 days.
Consumer Confidence Just Hit a Record Low. Here’s Why
Consumer sentiment has collapsed to a historic low of 49.8 amid the Iran conflict, surpassing levels seen during the pandemic and financial crisis. Economists warn this extreme pessimism is triggering demand destruction on durable goods, while corporations brace for significant cost headwinds from elevated energy prices.