Rahul Sagar on the Birth of Indian Nationalism
TL;DR
Political theorist Rahul Sagar uncovers the lost work of Narayan Mahadev Parmanand, a 19th-century intellectual whose anonymous writings constitute the first indigenous Indian political theory, revealing a distinctive liberal tradition focused on building capable states to combat social tyranny while binding monarchs' power through constitutional means.
🔍 The Anonymous Architect 3 insights
Deliberate obscurity erased a founder
Parmanand intentionally concealed his authorship of influential texts, including his editorship of "Native Opinion" (India's first Indian-owned newspaper) and "Letters to an Indian Raja," resulting in his complete erasure from history until Sagar's research identified him in 2023.
From colonial chaos to constitutional thought
Born in 1838 amid the lawlessness following the Third Anglo-Maratha War (1818), Parmanand's experience of brigandage and state collapse shaped his conviction that liberalism must first construct functional states before limiting their power.
A whispered manuscript
Stricken with Parkinson's disease and unable to move or speak normally, Parmanand dictated his final political treatise from his deathbed in 1891, creating a systematic theory of constitutional monarchy for Indian princely states.
⚖️ Indian vs. Western Liberalism 2 insights
Building Leviathan versus limiting it
Unlike European liberals who confronted existing powerful states, Indian liberals faced the absence of any state apparatus after 1818, forcing them to justify and construct tax systems and bureaucracies before they could constrain them.
Social tyranny as the primary threat
Parmanand viewed caste panchayats, polygamy, hereditary privileges, and religious superstitions as more immediate threats to liberty than state power, requiring a strong but bound monarch to break these entrenched social shackles.
🏛️ Architecture of Indigenous Reform 3 insights
Binding the monarch's hands
Parmanand's theory demanded that Maharajas voluntarily constrain their own arbitrary power through rule of law and institutional checks, creating a distinctively Indian "liberal connective tissue" separate from both British colonialism and traditional despotism.
Education as the foundation of liberty
The letters advocate for simultaneous education of rulers and citizens alongside merit-based bureaucratic recruitment, recognizing that liberal institutions require both a trained administrative class and an informed civil society to function.
Endogenous political theory
Rather than importing Enlightenment concepts wholesale, Parmanand developed an indigenous political theory rooted in local conditions, addressing specifically Indian problems of governance while employing universal liberal principles.
Bottom Line
Authentic liberal reform in developing contexts requires simultaneously building capable state institutions to dismantle deep-rooted social tyrannies while immediately constraining that power through constitutional mechanisms, meritocratic education, and an active civil society.
More from Conversations with Tyler (Tyler Cowen)
View all
Laura K. Field on the Making of the MAGA New Right
Laura K. Field analyzes the MAGA New Right as a deliberate intellectual movement (2016-2024) that rejects classical liberalism and Reagan-era fusionism in favor of nationalist economics, secure borders, and America First foreign policy, tracing its ideological radicalization through figures like Michael Anton and the Claremont Institute.
Sajjid Chinoy on Whether India Faces another 1991 Moment
Economist Sajjid Chinoy argues that while India has resolved supply-side constraints and cleaned up corporate balance sheets post-COVID, the economy now faces a binding demand-side crisis exacerbated by the largest energy shock in history, requiring a fundamental policy shift from macro stability toward structural employment generation to trigger private investment.
Sajjid Chinoy on Whether India Faces another 1991 Moment
While India is not facing a 1991-style balance of payments crisis, the economy is constrained by weak private investment due to insufficient demand, Chinese import competition, and fiscal pressures from welfare spending crowding out infrastructure investment, necessitating a policy pivot toward employment and exports.
Emily Chamlee-Wright — 2025 Markets and Society Conference Keynote
Liberal democracy faces collapse from both overt constitutional violations and the 'great forgetting' of its foundational principles. Chamlee-Wright argues that reversing this decay requires repairing liberalism's 'soft tissue'—the shared mental models, automatic norms, and cultural tools that make formal institutions function and scale.